Secondary and Post 16 Education Reorganisation

Committee for Education, Sport & Culture - P.2021/69

Original PropositionThe States are asked to decide:-Whether, after consideration of the policy letter, dated 28 th May, 2021, they are of the opinion:-1. To agree that from the earliest date practicable, States' maintained secondary education should be delivered through an 11-18 learning partnership across three 11-16 schools and a Sixth Form Centre located on a site separate to those schools, and Le Murier and Les Voies Schools and St Anne's School in Alderney.2. To agree the three 11-16 schools will be located on the existing school sites at Les Beaucamps, Les Varendes and St Sampson's and the Sixth Form Centre in a new building at Les Ozouets Campus co-located with The Guernsey Institute, the development and implementation of which is estimated to have:      a) A capital cost of £43.5m as set out in table 8 in paragraph 9.4; and     b) An ongoing revenue cost which will not, in the medium term, exceed the current revenue costs associated with these phases of education.3. To approve 'Secondary & Post 16 Education Reorganisation' as a project in the capital portfolio, subject to ratification by the States as part of the Government Work Plan debate.4. To delegate authority to the Policy & Resources Committee, following approval of the necessary business cases, to open capital votes of up to £54m, (which includes an allowance for optimism bias as described in section 9.8) to fund the model for the reorganisation of the secondary and post 16 education infrastructure agreed by the Assembly, subject to ratification by the States as part of the Government Work Plan debate.  The above Propositions have been submitted to Her Majesty's Procureur for advice on any legal or constitutional implications in accordance with Rule 4(1) of the Rules of Procedure of the States of Deliberation and their Committees.AmendmentsAmendmentsProposer SeconderStatusVoting RecordProcedural Votes Taken (if any)  Amendment 1 [380kb]Deputy CameronDeputy de SausmarezLostPour 17; Contre 22 Voting Record - Amendment 1 [165kb]    Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion [169kb]  Amendment 2 [240kb]Deputy LeadbeaterDeputy de LisleLostPour 14; Contre 22; Abstain 3  Voting Record - Amendment 2 [169kb]   Amendment 3 [235kb]Deputy LeadbeaterDeputy de LisleLostPour 12: Contre 27  Voting Record - Amendment 3 [166kb]   Amendment 4 [332kb]Deputy Le TocqDeputy CameronNot debatedMotion under Rule 24(6) was successful so the Amendment was not not debated and no vote taken  Rule 24(6) Motion [170kb]  Amendment 5 [255kb]Deputy Le TocqDeputy BrouardLostPour 14; Contre 22; Abstain 2; Absent 1 Voting Record - Amendment 5 [167kb]   Amendment 6 [322kb]Deputy St PierDeupty CameronNot Laid    Amendment 7 [252kb]Deputy St PierDeputy CameronNot Laid    Amendment 8 [255kb]Deputy TrottDeputy ParkinsonLostPour 16; Contre 20; Abstain 1 Voting Record - Amendment 8 [165kb] Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion [168kb]  Amendment 9 [260kb]Deputy MatthewsDeputy GollopNot laid as motion to suspend the Rules failed  Motion to suspend the Rules [170kb]  Amendment 10 [248kb]Deputy St PierDeputy CameronNot laid as motion to suspend the Rules failed  Motion to suspend the Rules [169kb]  Amendment 11 [251kb]Deputy St PierDeputy CameronLostPour 11; Contre 23; Abstain 4; Absent 2 Amendment 11 [167kb] Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion [169kb]