Policy & Resources Committee - P.2022/11
Original PropositionsThe States are asked to decide:-Whether, after consideration of the policy letter entitled 'Establishment of a Development Agency' dated 31 st January 2022, they are of the opinion:-1. To direct the Policy & Resources Committee to establish a development agency as a company limited by guarantee, wholly owned by the States of Guernsey, that will be tasked with (a) the production of a long-term development plan setting out the options for the provision of infrastructure along Guernsey's east coast working within the strategic direction set out in this policy letter; and (b) the delivery of the development associated with such options, working to the operating principles set out in this policy letter;2. To agree to establish the political oversight group (set out in paragraph 5.9.2.7);3. To direct the Policy & Resources Committee to invest seed funding of £1 million in total for the first two years of the establishment of the development agency (see section 7);4. To direct the Policy & Resources Committee to (a) establish a clear land management transfer policy; and (b) consult with the States' Trading Supervisory Board on the areas of land to be transferred from the States to the development agency; and (c) to effect that transfer once the development agency is established; and5. To direct the Development & Planning Authority to complete the Local Planning Briefs for the St Peter Port and St Sampson Harbour Action Areas by December 2022.Propositions (As Amended)Amendments 1 to 6 and 12 were Carried and as a result the Propositions were amended as detailed in the PDF below Propositions (as amended) [155kb]Voting Records on the Propositions (As Amended)Voting Record Proposition 1 [166kb] CarriedPour 34; Contre 1; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 1a [167kb] CarriedPour 26; Contre 9; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 2 [165kb] CarriedPour 28; Contre 7; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 2a [167kb] CarriedPour 30; Contre 5; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 3 [164kb] CarriedPour 24; Contre 11; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 3a [167kb] CarriedPour 26; Contre 7; Abstain 2; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 4 [162kb] CarriedPour 24; Contre 11; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 5 [166kb] CarriedPour 33; Contre 2; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 6a [167kb] CarriedPour 25; Contre 9; Abstain 1; Absent 4Voting Record Proposition 6b [166kb] CarriedPour 26; Contre 8; Abstain 1; Absent 4Amendments and their Voting RecordsAmendment 1 Deputy Oliver & Deputy Taylor [189kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 1CarriedAmendment 2 Deputy Burford & Deputy Soulsby [290kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 2CarriedAmendment 3 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [484kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 3CarriedAmendment 4 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [523kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 4CarriedAmendment 5 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [481kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 5CarriedAmendment 6 Deputy St Pier & Deputy Helyar [470kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 6CarriedVoting Record Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion to close debate - Deputy Inder [166kb] CarriedPour 23; Contre 11; Abstain 3; Absent 2Amendment 7 Deputy Gollop & Deputy de Lisle [496kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 7 Successful Motion under Rule 24(6). As a result the amendment was not debated and no vote takenAmendment 8 Deputy Meerveld & Deputy Burford [190kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 8LostVoting Record Voting Record - Amendment 8 [168kb] LostPour 10; Contre 24; Abstain 2; AbsentAmendment 9 Deputy Roffey & Deputy Parkinson [269kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 9LostVoting Record Voting Record - Amendment 9 [167kb] LostPour 15; Contre 19; Abstain 2; Absent 3Amendment 10 Deputy de Sausmarez & Deputy Soulsby [220kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 10Not laidAmendment 11 Deputy Roffey & Deputy Parkinson [336kb]P.2022/11 Amdt 11Successful Motion under Rule 24(6). As a result the amendment was not debated and no vote takenVoting Record Motion under Rule 24(6) that Amendment 11 not be debated and no vote taken [171kb] CarriedPour 18; Contre 14; Absent 7Amendment 12 Deputy de Sausmarez & Deputy Soulsby [221kb]P.2022/12 Amdt 12CarriedVoting Record CarriedPour 22: Contre 11; Abstain 2; Absent 4Voting Record Rule 26(1) Guillotine motion to close debate - Deputy Prow [168kb] CarriedPour 20; Contre 13; Abstain 2; Absent 4