22nd November 2023

Development & Planning Authority

Items on the Order Paper for this meeting will be listed as they become known

Watch the States of Deliberation Meeting onlineStates' Meetings are broadcast on Microsoft Teams Live and are also available to watch back afterwards if you missed any of the live broadcast. Links to each session of the Meetings are available to view by selecting a link below.Instructions for joining a Teams Live Event [334kb ]Livestream MorningAfternoonWednesday 22 nd November 2023https://bit.ly/3MPN1zhhttps://bit.ly/3sILX9sThursday 23 rd November 2023https://bit.ly/47HY7OHhttps://bit.ly/3Gb5PFpFriday 24 th November 2023https://bit.ly/47Ltzf9https://bit.ly/47F8GSIElectronic Voting RecordsFull details of votes taken at this Meeting will be published here  Simultaneous Electronic Voting Statements Statement to be given byTopicCommittee for Employment & Social SecurityGeneral UpdateDevelopment & Planning AuthorityGeneral UpdateCommittee for Health & Social CareGeneral UpdateOverseas Aid & Development CommissionGeneral UpdateA link to each statement is published once it has been delivered in the States Meeting. The Statements were deferred to the States' Meeting scheduled for Wednesday 13th December 2023. Questions (Rule 11)From:To:QuestionsDeputy GollopCommittee  for the Environment & Infrastructure1. The recent success of the We are Guernsey Green Finance week conference and fringe events showed the impact of offsetting environment loss, investment gains in biodiversity and ethical investment opportunities. Will the Committee seek increased partnership possibilities with the corporate sector locally?  2. The Green Party Conference (which I attended) had a session showing how light pollution& activity had changed starling bird migration patterns and other consequences. Will the Committee be considering new designs to protect our wildlife habitat and diversity?From:To:QuestionsDeputy SoulsbyCommittee  for Education, Sport & Culture1. In response to Rule 14 questions, the Committee has explained that the GCSE results have yet to be validated following the completion of the formal appeals process. What is the overall percentage of results in mathematics that have been successfully appealed since 2019?  2. The Committee has advised, in response to the same Rule 14 questions, that the proportion of students who achieved Level 4 and above in mathematics GCSE was 57.7% and at Level 7 and above was 10.8%. Accepting that these results are as yet unvalidated, what was the percentage attained at each of the States-maintained secondary schools?  3. How many specialist mathematics teachers are there currently in each of the  States-maintained secondary schools?From:To:QuestionsDeputy GollopCommittee  for Education, Sport & Culture1. Recently the ESC President rightly praised Beau Sejour centre the theatre Eisteddfod and activities but said it wasn't washing its face financially and needed review.. When will the review conclude and will politicians as well as officers be involved in thus Review process?  2. Will the Review look at and especially consider diverse socioeconomic factors such as the Centre's contributions to combatting loneliness, supporting equity and diversity .mental health and well being and supporting juvenile and elderly people's activity?   3. The Public accounts Scrutiny review chaired by Deputy Heidi Soulsby in November 2015 considered it undesirable to outsource or privatise the leisure centre . Will that option be reconsidered as well as enhancing Beau Sejour centre income? The Questions and their replies will be published in Hansard in due course. The Questions were deferred to the States' Meeting scheduled for Wednesday 13th December 2023. Items adjourned from the Meeting on  7th November 2023Billet d'ÉtatBillet ArticleCommittee/BodyTitleProposition ReferenceStatusXVIII1Policy & Resources Committee  The States of Guernsey Budget Report for 2024 [3Mb]P.2023/114Propositions carried apart from Propositions 13, 18, 18A and 19 Voting records Proposition 1Proposition 2Proposition 3Proposition 4Proposition 5Proposition 6Proposition 7Proposition 8Proposition 9Proposition 10Proposition 11Proposition 11AProposition 12Proposition 13Proposition 14Proposition 15Proposition 16Proposition 16AProposition 17Proposition 18Proposition 18AProposition 19Proposition 20Proposition 21Proposition 21AProposition 22Proposition 23Proposition 24  Amendment 1  Deputy Burford & Deputy Soulsby [202kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 1Motion under Rule 24(6) was successful. Voting Record Therefore the Amendment was not debated and no vote taken.  Amendment 2  Deputy Le Tissier & Deputy de Lisle [203kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 2Lost Voting Record  Amendment 3  Deputy Prow & Deputy Vermeulen [217kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 3Carried Voting Record  Amendment 4  Deputy Roffey & Deputy Gabriel [202kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 4Not laid  Amendment 5   Deputy St Pier & Deputy Taylor [243kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 5Motion under Rule 24(6) was successful. Voting RecordTherefore the Amendment was not debated and no vote taken.  Amendment 6  Deputy Gollop & Deputy Matthews [195kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 6Lost Voting Record  Amendment 7  Deputy Oliver & Deputy Dyke [202kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 7Not laid  Amendment 8  Deputy St Pier & Deputy Meerveld [215kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 8Not laid  Amendment 9  Deputy St Pier & Deputy Meerveld [193kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 9Not laid  Amendment 10  Deputy de Sausmarez & Gabriel [221kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 10Carried Voting Record  Amendment 11  Deputy de Sausmarez & Gabriel [282kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 11Carried Voting Record  Amendment 12  Deputy Dudley-Owen & Deputy Aldwell [433kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 12Lost Voting Record  Amendment 13  Deputy de Lisle & Deputy McKenna [212kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 13Lost Voting Record  Amendment 14  Deputy Roffey & Deputy Matthews [208kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 14Lost Voting Record  Amendment 15  Deputy Dyke & Deputy Vermeulen [207kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 15Lost Voting Record  Amendment 16   Deputy Heylar & Deputy Ferbrache [440kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 16Carried Voting Record  Amendment 17  Deputy Helyar & Deputy Mahoney [196kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 17Carried Voting Record  Amendment 18  Deputy Kazantseva-Miller & Deputy Murray [213kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 18Lost Voting Record  Amendment 19  Deputy Helyar & Deputy Mahoney [410kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 19Not laid   Amendment 20  Deputy Parkinson & Deputy St Pier [228kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 20Lost Voting Record  Amendment 21  Deputy St Pier & Deputy Soulsby [222kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 21Lost Voting Record  Amendment 22  Deputy Helyar & Deputy Mahoney [413kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 22Carried Voting Record  Amendment 23  Deputy Murray & Deputy Ferbrache [234kb]P.2023/114 Amdt 23Lost Voting RecordXVIII2Committee  for Employment & Social Security   P 2023 113 Non-contributory benefit rates for 2024 [565kb]P.2023/113Carried Voting RecordItems adjourned from the Meeting on  17th October 2023Billet d'ÉtatArticleCommitteeTitleProposition ReferenceStatusXIX1States' Trading Supervisory BoardAppointment of Non-Executive Directors - Guernsey Post LimitedP.2023/100Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XIX2Policy & Resources CommitteePublic Notaries (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Law, 2023P.2023/99Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XIX3Policy & Resource Committee Government Work Plan 2023-25P.2023/96Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting   Amendment 1  Deputy Kazantseva-Miller & Deputy Soulsby [202kb]P.2023/96 Amdt 1Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting   Amendment 2   Deputy Dudley-Owen & Deputy Cameron [240kb]P.2023/96 Amdt 2Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting   Amendment 3   Deputy Meerveld & Deputy McKenna [232kb]P.2023/96 Amdt 3Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting Legislation laid before the StatesThe Foundations (Guernsey) Law, 2012 (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023 (Commencement) Regulations, 2023The Limited Liability Partnerships (Guernsey) Law, 2013 (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023 (Commencement) Regulations, 2023Foundations (Guernsey) Law, 2012 (Amendment - Record Keeping etc) Regulations, 2023Limited Liability Partnerships (Guernsey) Law, 2013 (Amendment - Record Keeping etc) Regulations, 2023Limited Partnerships (Guernsey) Law, 1995 (Amendment) Regulations, 2023The Land Planning and Development (Visitor Accommodation) (Exemptions) Regulations, 2023The Employment and Equal Opportunities Service (Guernsey) Law, 2023 (Commencement) Regulations, 2023  LEGISLATION LAID BEFORE THE STATES [151kb]Legislation for ApprovalBillet d'ÉtatArticleCommitteeTitleProposition ReferenceStatusXIX4Committee  for Employment & Social SecurityThe Social Insurance (Rates of Contributions and Benefits etc.) Ordinance, 2023 P.2023/108Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XIX5Committee  for Employment & Social SecurityThe Long-term Care Insurance (Guernsey) (Rates) Ordinance, 2023 P.2023/109Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XIX6Policy & Resources CommitteeThe Sanctions and Terrorist Asset Freezing (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) Ordinance, 2023 P.2023/110Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XIX7Policy & Resources CommitteeThe Criminal Justice (Proceeds of Crime) (Bailiwick of Guernsey) (Amendment) (No. 5) Ordinance, 2023 P.2023/111Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting Propositions & Policy LettersBillet d'ÉtatArticle CommitteeTitleProposition ReferenceStatusXIX8Committee  for Employment & Social SecurityThe Prevention of Discrimination (Supported Employment) (Guernsey) Regulations, 2023P.2023/107Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XIX9Committee  for the Environment & InfrastructureTechnical Changes to Waste Shipment Legislation P.2023/112Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XX1Presiding OfficerElection of a Member of the States' Assembly & Constitution CommitteeP.2023/117Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XX2Deputy Parkinson & six othersMotion of No Confidence in the Policy & Resources CommitteeP.2023/118Debate started on Friday 24th November but was deferred to 13th December States' Meeting XIX10Policy & Resources Committee  Schedule for future States' business [264kb]P.2023/116Carried Voting RecordAppendix ReportAppendix ReportCommitteeMotion to debateStatus  Guernsey Police Complaints Commission 2021 & 2022 Annual Report [633kb]Committee  for Home Affairs  Deputy St Pier & Deputy Leadbeater [161kb]Deferred to 13th December States' Meeting   Guernsey Prison Annual Report 2022 [16Mb]Committee  for Home Affairs    Independant Monitoring Panel - Guernsey Prison - 2022 Annual Report [662kb]Committee  for Home Affairs