States Meeting

Policy & Resources Committee - The States of Guernsey Annual Budget for 2019, P.2018/108

The opening speech on the Budget given by the President of the Policy & Resources Committee can be read here

Please note that the amendments to the Budget are listed in numerical order below, however they were considered in accordance with the order on the Agenda in the downloads section on the right of this page.

• Voting on the Budget Propositions (as amended)

  • During the voting process separate votes were requested and taken on the Propositions listed below. All other Propositions were carried

  • 	Result of Vote	Recorded Vote (If requested)
    Proposition 4A	Carried	N/A
    Proposition 4B	Lost	Voting Record [271kb]
    Proposition 5	Carried	Voting Record [270kb]
    Proposition 6	Carried	N/A
    Proposition 14	Carried	Voting Record [270kb]
    Proposition 26	Carried	N/A
    Proposition 27	Carried	N/A
    Proposition 29	Carried	N/A
    Proposition 30	Carried	N/A
    Proposition 36	Carried	Voting Record [270kb]
    Proposition 41	Carried	N/A
    Proposition 47	Carried	Voting Record [270kb]
    Proposition 48	Carried	Voting Record [271kb]
    Proposition 53	Carried	Voting Record [271kb]
    Proposition 54	Carried	N/A

• Amendments to the Budget

  • Amendment	Proposer	Seconder	Result of Amendment	Recorded Vote (If requested)
    Amendment 1 [231kb]	Deputy Ferbrache	Deputy Kuttelwascher	Lost (Pour:16 Contre:23)	Voting Record [159kb]
    Amendment 2 [269kb]	Deputy Laurie Queripel	Deputy Yerby	Withdrawn before debate began
    Amendment 3 [487kb]	Deputy De Lisle	Deputy  Paint	Lost (Pour:18 Contre:20)	Voting Record [625kb]
    Amendment 4 [267kb]	Deputy Dorey	Deputy  Yerby	Carried (Pour:22 Contre:15)	Voting Record [356kb]
    Amendment 5 [270kb]	Deputy Lowe	Deputy  Prow	Carried
    Amendment 6 [275kb]	Deputy Dorey	Deputy Green	Withdrawn before debate began
    Amendment 7 [346kb]	Deputy Merrett	Deputy Oliver	Not Laid
    Amendment 8 [342kb]	Deputy Le Clerc	Deputy Langlois	Carried (Pour:31 Contre:7)	Voting Record [431kb]
    Amendment 9 [356kb]	Deputy Merrett	Deputy Yerby	Not Laid
    Amendment 10 [345kb]	Deputy Yerby	Deputy Merrett	A motion Under Rule 24(6) was carried therefore the amendment was not laid	Voting Record [106kb]
    Amendment 11 [272kb]	Deputy Yerby	Deputy Tindall	Carried (Pour:21 Contre:15)	Voting Record [362kb]
    Amendment 12 [268kb]	Deputy De Lisle	Deputy Paint	Lost (Pour:17 Contre:21)	Voting Record [357kb]
    Amendment 13 [265kb]	Deputy Laurie Queripel	Deputy Yerby	Lost (Pour:11 Contre:26)	Voting Record [355kb]
    Amendment 14 [344kb]	Deputy Yerby	Deputy Yerby	A motion Under Rule 24(6) was carried therefore the amendment was not laid	N/A
    Amendment 15 [272kb]	Deputy Merrett	Deputy Yerby	Lost (Pour: 5 Contre:34)	Voting Record [110kb]
    Amendment 16 [273kb]	Deputy Merrett	Deputy Yerby	Lost (Pour: 7 Contre:32)	Voting Record [110kb]
    Amendment 17 [267kb]	Deputy Soulsby	Deputy Merrett	Not Laid
    Amendment 18 [263kb]	Deputy Soulsby	Deputy Tooley	Not Laid
    Amendment 19 [270kb]	Deputy Soulsby	Deputy Tooley	Not Laid
    Amendment 20 [277kb]	Deputy Soulsby	Deputy Lowe	Not Laid
    Amendment 21 [268kb]	Deputy Yerby	Deputy Soulsby	Not Laid
    Amendment 22 [403kb]	Deputy Merrett	Deputy Fallaize(*)	Lost (Pour:19 Contre:20)	Voting Record [112kb]
    Amendment 23 [271kb]	Deputy Tindall	Deputy Soulsby	Not Laid
    Amendment 24 [274kb]	Deputy Le Tocq	Deputy Stephens	Rule 26(1) 'Guillotine' Motion - Lost (Pour:12 Contre:24)  Amendment - Carried	Voting Record [107kb] N/A
    Amendment 25 [200kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Brouard	Not Laid
    Amendment 26 [225kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Brouard	Not Laid
    Amendment 27 [259kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Brouard	Lost	N/A
    Amendment 28 [224kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Not Laid
    Amendment 29 [223kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Not Laid
    Amendment 30 [219kb]	Deputy Le Tocq	Deputy Stephens	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 31 [276kb]	Deputy Le Tocq	Deputy Stephens	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 32 [187kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried (Pour:25 Contre:12)	Voting Record [278kb]
    Amendment 33 [274kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 34 [259kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Not Laid
    Amendment 35 [277kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 36 [267kb]	Deputy Trott	Deputy Le Tocq	A motion Under Rule 24(6) was carried therefore the amendment was not laid	N/A
    Amendment 37 [183kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 38 [182kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 39 [260kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 40 [186kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 41 [188kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Carried	N/A
    Amendment 42 [300kb]	Deputy St Pier	Deputy Trott	Lost (Pour:13 Contre:25)	Voting Record [371kb]

  • (*) Amendment 22 was originally lodged on the 25th October. During the Budget debate on 6 November, Deputy Tooley confirmed she no longer wished to second the amendment and Deputy Fallaize agreed to second it instead.

Billet d'État XXVI:
 

• Elections and Appointments

  • Billet D'Etat	Billet Article	Title	Reference Number
    XXVI	1	Election of a President of the States' Assembly & Constitution Committee	P.2018/112
    XXVI	2	Election of three Members of the States' Assembly & Constitution Committee	P.2018/113 P.2018/114 P.2018/115